Emma Watson Discusses Additional Scene to "Deathly Hallows: Part 1" With SFX Magazine
October 17, 2010, 05:20 AM
Emma Watson (Hermione Granger) has spoken with SFX magazine about a scene added to the beginning of "Deathly Hallows: Part 1" that was not in the book:
[Director] David Yates asked Steve Kloves to write this lovely scene
at the beginning of the movie which is not in the book, but which I feel
is very important for Hermione’s character. You see her wiping her
parents’ memories in order for her to start off on the adventure with
Ron and Harry. She knows that Voldemort could try to use her parents as a
device to get to her in some way, which means they might be in harm’s
way. So she wipes their memories so they forget she ever existed. All
the photos of her around the house disappear. It’s a really tough way
for the film to start but really important to see the sacrifices that
she has to make.
The upcoming issue of SFX will have a behind-the-scenes feature on "Deathly Hallows: Part 1."
Well, technically, it was in the book. We just didn’t get to see it because Harry wasn’t there to witness the details. But still, I’m glad they created a scene to reveal Hermione’s situation. It makes me wonder, though, if she had any support from the wizarding community at such a difficult moment or did she have to sort out and make the decision on her own?
I am actually excited to see this scene. Usually adding things makes me a little annoyed, but this seems like it will fit so much better then the burning burrow into the storyline.
Yeah, I can see how this would be a good scene. But, I really don’t trust David Yates with anything. I think maybe it would be better if they just mentioned it, like in the book.
what a happy thought
If the scene enhances the story, I won’t mind it so much. I mean, the addition of the story of Lily’s fish gift to Slughorn was excellent.
But usually I don’t like additional scenes as evidenced by the Burrow scene in HBP & pretty much everything in Jackson’s LOTR films.
I was mad at first when I saw that Steve Kloves was writing another scene, but when I read what the scene was… Finally they add a scene enhances the story and doesn’t distract from it. I couldn’t be happier about it!
I honestly don’t have a problem with the Burrow scene in HBP. People say they “added a scene” but I look at it more they took the Death Eaters attacking Hogwarts at the end of the book and put it in the middle and setting it at the Burrow.
i dont think that scene is so important enough to start the film….
People keep commenting “Technically, it was in the book because Hermione mentioned it.” I think everyone reading this page ALREADY KNOWS that Hermione mentioned it. The article states that there’s a SCENE added that wasn’t in the book. This scene was not in the book, so why the “Technically…”?
@ Nutty: Because the scene at least builds on information in the book, as apposed to the opening coffee shop scene added to HBP, which absolutely flies in the face of what takes place in the book.
I get that the information was in the book, but the SCENE wasn’t, which was what the article said in the first place.
Well I’ve seen the film, and believe me this scene was beautifully done and extremely moving, i had tears in my eyes as I watched it.