I’d love to hear this as well! If not the whole thing, at the very least feature the best parts on PotterCast. It’s no secret that I’m no Twilight fan whatsoever, but seeing the two mix at this level would be very interesting regardless.

Twilight is going down. It can’t hold a candle to Potter. The characters, the plot, and the writing of Potter are all miles and miles ahead of the pitiful dribble that is Twilight.

This does sound really interesting. I wish that I could go, but there would be absolutely no way for me to get to NYC by tomorrow. I do agree with others that it would be cool if it is recorded for those that can’t attend. I love both book series, even though they completely different from one another (which is why I hate it when they are compared to one other). I am going to use a quote from a woman at LeakyCon because she said it better than I could ever describe it. She said something along the lines that “Harry Potter is your soulmate and Twilight is that incredibly hot weekend fling.” This pretty much sums up my feelings of the two book series. I have been to six HP cons (in various countries), have multiple HP tattoos, and spent thousands of dollars and hours on HP and things related to HP, things that I really doubt that I will be doing for Twilight. -——————— I find the people (and the media) that want to start a fandom war between Harry Potter and Twilight immature and, to be quite honest, pathetic. I know that fans of one book might not like the other, but calling the other “stupid” or “gross” or any other of these little names is both juvenile and rude. I would think that Harry Potter fans (and Twilight fans) would be able to state their dislike without being insulting and disrespectful.

That sounds so cool.

I wish i was in NY for this! I hope we get a detailed report on what happens =)

this news pisses me off! why oh why they have to mix the brilliant magical amazing HP with that stupid book!? they’re totally different! Grr!

This looks cool. Wish I could see it. Any chance of it on an episode of PotterCast?

Oh no, seriously? And people wonder why the media constantly compares the two.

I absolutely agree with goodegogo: NOTHING can beat HP! NOTHING!!!! I read all the Twilight books. They are good. But They can’t be compared with HP! HP is more interesting, there are less cliche and the story is much more difficult to predict while reading the first book! :)))))

barfs twilight barfs again oh god make it stop!

This would be interesting to listen to! Please do record!!!

Melissa please, please PLEASE crush the Twilight guy to the ground!!

(Sorry my pure hatred for Twilght is making me come over all Slytherinish!)

This sounds great! I’d love to be able to go, since based on who is participating, it sounds like it will be an intelligent discussion, rather than the immature name-calling that tends to take place in comments every time the two series are mentioned together.

I’m tempted to jump in my car right now and head down, but as the car has been giving me problems, I’m not sure it’s up for the 4 hr drive. Oh well, I will look forward to hearing about the event later.

Oooohhhh I would love to hear it too!!! Can you PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE record it??? There is no way I can get on a plane to NY for this …
I haven’t read the Twilight series yet (still waiting for my cousin to lend me her original versions) because I don’t want the translated stuff, but I admit I’m really curious. Also, why do people have to bad-mouth the series? Geez, if you don’t like it it’s fine, it’s not a reason to talk meanly about things! Don’t you feel hurt when you read/hear people talking badly about HP? Don’t do the same they do!

Hope you have a great time tonight Melissa!

o wow! amazing! I want the video!