This is how I think Deathly Hallows should be split:

Right when the trio are listening to Potterwatch in the tent, then Harry says the taboo name Voldemort, and the death eaters appear outside the tent. Then the screen goes black and we hear the chilling voice of Amycus Carrow threatening them, and then the credits come! It would be so creepy and awesome!!

the ending must be some sort of cliffhanger i think “are you reffering to the deathly hallows” then just cut to black would be PERFECT

then DH 2 could go right into the tale of the three brothers (whcih could be a flashback scene with them talking in V.O. instead of them just telling the story

For the guys in India, wanted to inform you about POTTER MANIA on Cartoon Network Channel starting 29th December every Sunday. All five of them!! This is for all Potter fans in India!!! Have fun! Merry Christmas to all of you anywhere in the world.

thank you don’t come again this article is bout the dh split

thank you

Gotta be either the bit where Ron leaves or the bit where he comes back and detroys the locket. I hope it’s this bit because then the trio will be back together – surely a perfect point to break?!
xx

Sorry me again – (I commented above!)

A brainwave just occured to me that has made me dead set on the – “Ron destroying the locket breaking point” – because when the locking is taunting and teasing him and playing with his mind it is very powerful and emotional.

IT HAS TO BE THAT PART!

xx

I’ve always thought the best part that would be the easiest/most emotional/climactic point to break the film would be when Ron leaves. I know a lot of people have agreed (and disagreed) with this point. Visually in the books it’s about half way. What that translates to in the movie though is very emotional—not necessarily happy either. But what follows for the next film is Godrics Hollow, and i think that would be a spectacular place to start with. High action in the beginning. :D

I’m glad HBP is 2.5 hours. That’ll make all the difference. :)

Hmmmm…very happy about the length of time in HBP….not happy about the length of wait time for it to come out…but oh well :)…….All the ideas that I have read on here sound really good and feasible. I’m not really sure where I think it should be broken. I think it would be my fantasy ending for it to fade to black as Hermione looks up as Ron and Harry enter the tent when Ron comes back to them. Of, course then you have to do the Hr/R fight scene right in the beginning of the 2nd movie which might be ok…like I said , I don’t know. I agree with whoever posted the comment about putting the epilogue after the credits of the 2nd movie is right on. They did that with Pirates of the Carribean: At World’s End and it work, but a lot of movie goers might miss it if they don’t know there is an epilogue. Just my opinion though :)

ron leaving=too early in the book crams 2nd film
ron returning=no suspense there at all i dunno y thats so popular

I agree with adam- ron leaving is way too early, and it would rush everything in the second film.

All the other suggestions seem alright though, they all seem appropriate i don’t know what to pick.

Scarletti: “I’ve always thought the best part that would be the easiest/most emotional/climactic point to break the film would be when Ron leaves. I know a lot of people have agreed (and disagreed) with this point. Visually in the books it’s about half way. What that translates to in the movie though is very emotional—not necessarily happy either.”

I agree, it’s cerainly a veeeery emotional scene. But like others have said, it’s too early in the book. And.. Heyman said something about splitting at a moment of truth and there is no truth, absolutely no truth in the moment when Ron leaves. It makes it look like Ron is a coward and doesn’t care for his friends and we know both of that is a LIE. So a more truthful moment would be when Ron comes back. However, unless they change the movie’s title, I prefer to end it sometime after the audience would know what the Hallows are.

i think part one should end while they are in the ministry stealing slytherin’s locket.

So Angry That We Still Have To Wait Till July To See It….!

The Part Where Dobby Dies Or Where Ron Leaves Would Be A Good Part But No-ones Metioned Godrics Hollow. They Should End Part 1 JUst After The Snake Comes Out And Hermoine Bursts Into The Room,They Should Have Her Saying A Spell Which You Can’t Hear But There Should Be A Big Blinding Light. This Is Action Packed And Would Make People Emtional Because A Lot Of People Haven’t Read The Book So They Won’t Know That There Are No Deaths Just Then…!

Can’t Wait For This Film To Come Out..! I Qued 6 And A Half Hours For The Last Book…!

Does Anyone Know If Theres Still Gunna B A Harry Potter Encyclopedia?

HPB is about two and a half hours sweet…….