Hmm… Would this be when Ron leaves?

wow… so we might get the silver doe break after all

When Ron leaves is a very emotional part of the story, it would be a good place!

Squee! The sixth movie is two hours and a half!!

I wonder when the moment could be? I have two hopes for it:

1. When Lovegood says: “Are you referring to the sign of the Deathly Hallows?” to the trio
2. When Ron leaves the trio

I hope they don’t cut the wedding scene at the start. Emma will look as wonderful in the purple ball gown as she did in the pink Yule Ball gown in GOF.

Rupert has a huge part to play. Some of Ron’s finest moments are in the Deathly Hallows. Such as his return.

Dan will get it right, as usual. As long as he looks engaged when other characters are talking.

As long as the director doesn’t do any weird camera shots like they did in number 5, with zooming in close ups and things. Please. Keep. True. To . The. Book. They didn’t keep very true in OOTP, which annoyed me.

That’s my two cents.

I officially have all of my money on Part I ending when Ron returns and destroys the locket. It’s emotional and full of truth. So it’d be perfect,

It will be when ron leaves or when ron comes back. I hope it’s when he leaves because i guess ron is really truthful in what he says to Harry. whatever part it will be great :D

What about when Dobby dies – i would say that would be a great moment for a break, as its when Harry really grasps what needs to happen!!!

i agree … when dobby dies and harry walks to the house thinking “horcrux or hallows”.

Two hours and half is great. I really hope so. Because it will beter than 2 hours. I gross my fingers. You too, won’t you?!

In my opinion, the best end to part one would be when Harry breaks the charms by saying “Voldemort” and they are grabbed by the snatchers. That would have the second movie starting basically at Malfoy Manor. By then everything has been established for the big action: Dobby, Gringotts and the Battle of Hogwarts. But since they rarely do what I think they should, I wouldn’t count on it.

When Dobby dies is the best!

My money’s on when Ron comes back….well, after Hermione trys to beat the snot out of him….and I’m happy that the sixth movie is 2 1/2 hours long!!!

Still not happy about waiting ’til July….

the break has GOT to be Dobby’s death, and the beginnings of the time at Shell Cottage… 1) Malfoy Manor is an amazing climax… of them getting caught, of Pettigrew dying, hermione getting tortured, Griphook and Ollivander being freed and Dobby dying… It’s a huge climax followed by an emotional upheaval of Dobby’s burial and the setup for the rest of the story. This leaves Part 2 to begin with the planning of the Gringott’s robbery.

It’s an extremely natural place for the story to be broken apart, in terms of story arc and character development.

I would have liked Tristan’s idea to be used—-break it at:
“when Lovegood says: “Are you referring to the sign of the Deathly Hallows?” to the trio"

That would have worked brilliantly, imo. It would not be the expected emotional/action scene for a break. It would really leave the next movie on a note of intrigue (yes, we have read the book, but still!) Unfortunately (well the break is still good), they’re going for one of the more emotional cuts.

I don’t like to brag, but I did tell you guys HBP would be 2 1/2 hrs about two months ago. Kinda sad, innit, that a lot of Voldy’s past was cut despite the lengthier running time. Well, it’s still a good movie, but I hope they release extras in the Ginormous HP Collector Blu-ray set of doom, which are all the cut memories. That would be awesome.

I have to say this once more though, mmmmmmmm, HBP cinematography, mmm

I think it will be when Ron returns and kills the locket too. Its not action packed but has lots of truth in it. GOD I can’t wait for this movie!