MyLeaky Login

Join the largest Harry Potter Social Network on the Web! | FAQ

In the News

Harry Potter Lexicon Makes Statement Regarding Suit

Companion Books
Posted by: Melissa
November 05, 2007, 03:55 AM

Steve Vander Ark of the Harry Potter Lexicon has added a statement about the recent lawsuit, as well as a link to a page on RDR with information on and the ability to order the book, on the Harry Potter Lexicon. Text is below. You can read about the filed lawsuit and J.K. Rowling’s statements here, and statements from WB and RDR here.

The statement is:


Dear Friends,

I would like to thank each and every one of you for your support in recent days. Everyone here at the Lexicon, all volunteers, regrets the unpleasantness. We have always been interested in working with the publishers of the novels to satisfy their concerns, interests and needs and we certainly do not plan nor have we ever planned to publish anything which competes with Ms. Rowling’s fine literary capabilities. Our work has nothing to do with fiction writing and is only concerned with legitimate critical analysis and academic considerations. It has been widely approved and employed by Ms. Rowling herself.

My book was started in response to many, many people who talked to me and asked if there could be a print version of the Lexicon, not in some sort of attempt to profit off of fans. Because the material for the book was not only accepted but praised and used frequently by every entity concerned with creating the Harry Potter books, games, and films, I would never have thought that a print version could be judged differently.

I sincerely hope that this matter can be resolved amicably and ask for you patience and understanding during that process.

Steve

Steve Vander Ark
The Harry Potter Lexicon


Again, you can read about the filed lawsuit and J.K. Rowling’s statements here, and statements from WB and RDR here. Also of note: RDR Books has amended its statement several times since TLC first posted it, most recently to add commentary following yesterday’s post about the WB and RDR Q-and-As.

Other new details are as follows: Following yesterday’s post which said there was a possibility that essays would be included in the Lexicon, several Lexicon essay writers have publicly said that they were not asked for permission to have their essay reprinted, and some essay writers have been assured by Lexicon staff that there will be no essays in the book at all. We have asked the publisher which is correct and will amend this post if we get an answer.

Update: RDR books answered our query with a lengthy statement that neither confirmed nor denied. We’ve asked for a more direct answer and have yet to receive one.

Update 2: TLC has received word via a reliable source that the initial email to Steve Vander Ark and RDR Books was phrased as an attempt to appeal to the Lexicon’s status as a site favored by J.K. Rowling. It also, according to the source, clearly named Warner Bros. as at stake and called Vander Ark a friend of the series and someone publishers/lawyers/agents were sure did not want to disrupt Rowling’s rights. RDR has called the email “threatening and abusive” and claimed that Warner Bros. only claimed rights after RDR sent them a letter regarding the timeline on the Harry Potter DVDs.

Also in the time since this issue began the book has risen from ranked lower than 230,000 in Amazon.co.uk books, to 7,034 as of this posting.

Update 3: A reader has commented that they ordered the book in the UK, which was slated to have a Nov. 5, 2007, publication date; the order was pushed back to January, 4, 2008, instead.


The Harry Potter Lexicon is a partner site to The Leaky Cauldron. The opinions and claims argued here do not constitute The Leaky Cauldron’s opinion or claim (of which it has none).

Previous Article | Next Article Browse all Recent Companion Books News

1640 Comments

Ken

hello YouTube Team, I like the different featured , http://corvette-air.koil.ze.cx/index.html corvette air conditioning, =-O, http://toyota-service.agritv.co.cc/waste-services.html waste services, >:D, http://san-jose.florida.osa.pl/san-antonio-shoes.html san antonio shoes, %-DDD, http://spanking-services.agritv.co.cc/travelers-tax-service.html travelers tax service, %PP, http://san-jose.florida.osa.pl/san-jose-improv.html san jose improv, adave, http://corvette-air.koil.ze.cx/allgiant-air.html allgiant air, 120063, http://united-cooperative.agritv.co.cc/service-costing.html service costing, etpfhf,

Posted by Ken on November 15, 2008, 09:29 AM report to moderator
Ded Mazai

for websites and that the content , http://reasonable-air.golodno.co.cc/nepal-budda-air.html nepal budda air, ssxb, http://san-francisco.florida.osa.pl/ipl-san-jose.html ipl san jose, %]]],

Posted by Ded Mazai on November 15, 2008, 10:27 AM report to moderator
Bill

can work together, so many people , http://choctaw-management.agritv.co.cc/telecheck-services-inc.html telecheck services inc, 275663, http://breathing-air.koil.ze.cx/atlantic-air-cargo.html atlantic air cargo, 23690, http://guardline-laundry.agritv.co.cc/shoraka-advisory-service.html shoraka advisory service, >:-OO, http://lasik-san.florida.osa.pl/san-diego-golf.html san diego golf, 8-P, http://san-antonia.florida.osa.pl/legoland-san-diego.html legoland san diego, 411128, http://air-tugger.golodno.co.cc/air-brushing.html air brushing, qxzq, http://wireless-laptop.agritv.co.cc/limousine-services-uk.html limousine services uk, 995646,

Posted by Bill on November 15, 2008, 11:10 AM report to moderator
Rax

videos to me, were featured on the UK homepage , http://san-prospero.florida.osa.pl/san-francisco-hostels.html san francisco hostels, kqqyoc, http://breathing-air.koil.ze.cx/air-tools-huddersfield.html air tools huddersfield, 72738, http://boston-architectur.agritv.co.cc/service-dog-vest.html service dog vest, 772, http://lake-san.florida.osa.pl/khe-san.html khe san, >:[, http://coleman-air.golodno.co.cc/misawa-air-base.html misawa air base, fkyhg, http://resume-writing.agritv.co.cc/mds-pharma-services.html mds pharma services, 202, http://shaw-customer.agritv.co.cc/russia-escort-service.html russia escort service, 613,

Posted by Rax on November 15, 2008, 11:53 AM report to moderator
adam

but I do wonder exactly how much attention , http://spanking-services.agritv.co.cc/dna-ancestry-services.html dna ancestry services, >:-OOO, http://coleman-air.golodno.co.cc/zinc-air-battery.html zinc air battery, 8((, http://service-uniforms.agritv.co.cc/remote-access-service.html remote access service, 8-]]], http://allegiant-air.golodno.co.cc/air-kennel.html air kennel, akw, http://home-air.koil.ze.cx/inexpensive-air-fare.html inexpensive air fare, elzru, http://guardline-laundry.agritv.co.cc/cleaning-services-cambridge.html cleaning services cambridge, 0924, http://lasik-san.florida.osa.pl/abdominoplasty-san-jose.html abdominoplasty san jose, :PPP,

Posted by adam on November 15, 2008, 12:52 PM report to moderator
Dana

users over the course of a year or even more., http://guardline-laundry.agritv.co.cc/homeward-bound-services.html homeward bound services, 29488, http://internet-merchant.agritv.co.cc/maine-warden-service.html maine warden service, =-(((,

Posted by Dana on November 15, 2008, 01:23 PM report to moderator
Bill

control what I can access for commercial reasons. , http://san-juan.florida.osa.pl/hyatt-san-diego.html hyatt san diego, yjndc, http://mortgage-contracti.agritv.co.cc/dj-services-toronto.html dj services toronto, kts, http://winnipeg-escort.agritv.co.cc/service-station-bmp.html service station bmp, 54810, http://spanking-services.agritv.co.cc/escourt-services.html escourt services, 8))), http://heil-air.koil.ze.cx/vornado-air-cleaner.html vornado air cleaner, tcscpo, http://harmony-dvds.hukol.co.cc/celtic-woman-dvd.html celtic woman dvd, =D, http://corvette-air.koil.ze.cx/honeywell-air-cleaners.html honeywell air cleaners, areejq,

Posted by Bill on November 15, 2008, 02:08 PM report to moderator
Leyla

Tough luck on that! , http://san-diego.florida.osa.pl/san-giuseppe.html san giuseppe, 56781, http://courier-delivery.agritv.co.cc/call-answering-service.html call answering service, 76793, http://shaw-customer.agritv.co.cc/service-temperature-polystyrene.html service temperature polystyrene, 40472, http://payne-air.golodno.co.cc/industrial-air-compressors.html industrial air compressors, 452, http://louise-wise.agritv.co.cc/toronto-paving-services.html toronto paving services, ppwj, http://san-benito.florida.osa.pl/san-antonio-preschool.html san antonio preschool, pnsc, http://rfp-internet.agritv.co.cc/used-service-trucks.html used service trucks, =-OO,

Posted by Leyla on November 15, 2008, 02:39 PM report to moderator
Phill Yasen

through exchanging thoughts about whatever comes to mind, etc. , http://national-clandesti.agritv.co.cc/octagon-risk-services.html octagon risk services, xlxtk, http://allegiant-air.golodno.co.cc/automatic-air-fresheners.html automatic air fresheners, qyll, http://san-antonia.florida.osa.pl/earthquake-san-francisco.html earthquake san francisco, >:-), http://internet-merchant.agritv.co.cc/6l45-transmission-service.html 6l45 transmission service, 867, http://dp-air.koil.ze.cx/air-biozone-purifier.html air biozone purifier, xfy, http://louisiana-civil.agritv.co.cc/service-star-flag.html service star flag, :-((, http://toyota-service.agritv.co.cc/sterling-financial-services.html sterling financial services, %DD,

Posted by Phill Yasen on November 15, 2008, 02:54 PM report to moderator
Jaxk

In the US, the threat is that companies , http://louise-wise.agritv.co.cc/harvard-tax-services.html harvard tax services, 964, http://san-francisco.florida.osa.pl/san-antonio-hospitals.html san antonio hospitals, 5189, http://san-francisco.florida.osa.pl/san-joaquin-valley.html san joaquin valley, 5935, http://toyotomi-air.koil.ze.cx/sanyo-air-conditioner.html sanyo air conditioner, :]], http://graveside-service.agritv.co.cc/inmate-messaging-services.html inmate messaging services, %], http://national-clandesti.agritv.co.cc/american-residential-services.html american residential services, jvlu, http://uk-passport.agritv.co.cc/raphael-service-apartment.html raphael service apartment, 999309,

Posted by Jaxk on November 15, 2008, 03:40 PM report to moderator
Samuel

doing with your time now that you’ve , http://underground-servic.agritv.co.cc/managed-billing-services.html managed billing services, hsm, http://san-antonia.florida.osa.pl/san-juan-23.html san juan 23, 461,

Posted by Samuel on November 15, 2008, 04:25 PM report to moderator
James Neiborn

It gives more people the chance , http://ny-limousine.agritv.co.cc/service-defination.html service defination, ubst, http://ks-gas.agritv.co.cc/tomales-community-services.html tomales community services, 8-[,

Posted by James Neiborn on November 15, 2008, 04:55 PM report to moderator
Bill Dyatel

when they find something distasteful or unreliable, , http://ram-air.golodno.co.cc/aviano-air-base.html aviano air base, %OO, http://united-cooperative.agritv.co.cc/hone-stabilization-services.html hone stabilization services, :-]]], http://san-carlos.florida.osa.pl/strippers-san-diego.html strippers san diego, 863, http://payne-air.golodno.co.cc/air-jordan-xx3.html air jordan xx3, hmc, http://nextel-phone.agritv.co.cc/coupon-clipping-service.html coupon clipping service, hzqa, http://corvette-air.koil.ze.cx/neck-air-conditioner.html neck air conditioner, 8]]], http://ford-san.florida.osa.pl/chaussettes-sans-elastique.html chaussettes sans elastique, mngkqm,

Posted by Bill Dyatel on November 15, 2008, 05:38 PM report to moderator
Samuel

20 years ago this would have been impossible. , http://mortgage-contracti.agritv.co.cc/map.html mortgage contracting services, vaj,

Posted by Samuel on November 15, 2008, 06:07 PM report to moderator
Jack

though it is against the long-term , http://louisiana-civil.agritv.co.cc/map.html louisiana civil service, 8336,

Posted by Jack on November 15, 2008, 06:20 PM report to moderator
You must be logged in to MyLeaky to comment. Please click here to log in.

Finding Hogwarts
PotterCast Interviews Jo Rowling! Click here to Listen! The Books Everything...Half-Blood Prince...and the rest of the HP Films Leaky Apps
Learn to knit your own 'Weasley Sweater'. Learn to brew your own 'Butterbeer'. Find out how at Leaky Crafts!

Scribbulus Essay Project

Issue 28 - Aug. 2014

Scribbulus is THE place for Leaky Cauldron readers to submit their essays and opinion pieces!
See more over at Scribbulus!

Guess That Book

On the threshold stood Aunt Marge. She was very like Uncle Vernon: large, beefy, and purple-faced, she even had a mustache, though not as bushy as his. In one hand she held an enormous suitcase, and tucked under the other was an old and evil-tempered bull